Menu - Timmy's Pizza and BBQ

Go to content
Delivery is now available all hours that we are open and delivery fees are discounted!
Paid online orders can now do curb-side pickup!
Call-in carry-out orders are encouraged to provide vehicle information as well so we can bring the food out to you!

Pizza is a perfect choice for lunch or dinner, turn every meal into a pizza party with Timmy's Pizza and BBQ!

To order over the phone, in the Huntertown area, call 260-637-7492 or in Garrett, call 260-357-6666.

Try one of our specialty pizzas or add your own toppings!
GLUTEN FRIENDLY PIZZA AVAILABLE - Medium Thin Crust Only - Add $3.00
A tantalizing taste of the Mexican border! Delicately seasoned taco meat  topped with freshest lettuce, onion, green peppers and plump tomatoes.  Topped off with the perfect blend of cheddar and mozzarella cheese and  that touch of tortilla chips (Salsa and sour cream available upon  request)

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
A blend of the finest ingrediants found anywhere in the world. This mouth watering pizza is loaded with Italian sausage complimented perfectly with just the right amount of pepperoni. Add in the freshest onions, green peppers, green olives and mushrooms. Smother it all in mozzerella cheese and you've got the pizza everyone will love.

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
The ultimate BBQ Pizza! Hickory-smoked pulled pork, sweet banana  peppers, onion, bacon and fresh tomatoes. Timmy's secret BBQ sauce  topped off with mozzarella and cheddar cheese.

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
A vegetarian's worst nightmare! A meat lovers fantasy. The "ALL MEAT  Pizza" loaded with sausage, fresh ground beef, scrumptious bacon  finished off with a layer of pepperoni and tender ham. A monster ham  pizza held together by a ton of fresh mozzarella cheese. Great for the  SERIOUS meat lover!

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
Smoked chicken loaded on our own not too tangy, not too sweet barbeque  sauce, green peppers, onions, ripe tomatoes and mozzarella cheese round  out this culinary masterpiece that's sure to addict even the slightest  chicken enthusiast!

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
The healthy escape to pizza.  Juicy vegetable toppings such as fresh  onions, green and black olives, thin sliced mushrooms, green peppers,  plump ripe tomatoesall covered with a generous portion of pure  mozzarella cheese (Banana and Jalapeño peppers added upon request)

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
If you like our hot, you're going to love our most popular spicy dish.  Smoked chicken marinated and laid in a southern style hot sauce, topped  off with a healthy portion of fresh onions and a mound of cheddar and  mozzarella cheeses. It's guaranteed to keep the taste buds awake!

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
The Western Specialty Pizza! Sausage, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers,  cheddar & mozzarella cheese. Made with our special BBQ sauce.

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
Pizza for one made delicious! This single serving pizza is like a  snowflake, no two are ever the same. Actual shape and size may vary, but  load these little guys up with your choice of toppings and results are  always the same, the best individual pizza on the planet!

2 Toppings $6.49 / Specialty $7.49 / Extra Toppings  add .75
Smoked chicken, bacon, onions, green peppers, fresh tomatoes and mozzarella cheese on a creamy white sauce.

12" Med. $14.49 8 PC / 14" $17.49 10 PC
Your way!
Make It Chicago Style
Extra Cheese, extra topping, double crust and secret spice.
Med. add $4.00 / Lg. add $5.00
Make It Pan Style
Med. add $1.00 / Lg. add $2.00

  Pizza, Ranch, Bleu Cheese, BBQ & Garlic

Regular Toppings
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Beef, green peppers, banana peppers, onions, jalopenos, green and black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, pineapple.

Special Toppings
Bacon, Chicken

1 Regular Topping
12" $10.00 / 14" $13.00

2 Regular Toppings
12" $11.00/ 14"  $14.00

3 Regular Toppings
12" $12.00 / 14" $15.00

Regular Toppings (each)
$1.50 extra / $2.00 extra

Special Toppings (each)
$2.00 extra / $3.00 extra

Extra cheese
$2.00 extra / $3.00 extra

Extra Sauce
$.75 extra / $1.00 extra

Italian white bread with garlic butter, cheese and Greek seasoning

Hand-stretched pizza dough with a garlic butter, cheese & Greek seasoning


Try Our Mouthwatering BBQ
If you've never tried the BBQ at Timmy's Pizza and BBQ, you're missing  out. Do yourself a favor and order our ribs, a pulled pork sandwich and sides!

Our locally and family-owned restaurant has 18  years of BBQ-making experience, so rely on us for food that will excite  your taste buds.

All BBQ is smoked with hickory.
Shredded BBQ Pork Sandwich
Shredded BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Shredded BBQ Brisket Brisket Sandwich
BBQ Pulled Pork Nacho Platter
Tortilla chips covered with blend of Mozarella and Cheddar Cheese,  Smoked Pulled Pork thenn smothered with lettuce, onions, tomatoes,  banana peppers & jalapeños.

Pulled Pork, Mac & Cheese, Baked Beans and Award winning BBQ Sauce.

Ribs, Ribs, Ribs!
Make it a Complete Dinner with Any 2 Sides for only $2.00 more!

Slab $11.49 / Full Slab $21.00
Sides Available
Baked Beans, Potato Salad, Potato Chips, Cole Slaw, Applesauce, Mac and Cheese, and Corn Bread
Pint of Barbecue Sauce
Hickory Smoked Wings - Hot, Mild, Teriyaki & BBQ
6 pc

12 pc

25 pc

Feed 4 - $28.00
"That's $7.00 per person, what a deal!"
Choose 2 pounds of pulled pork or pulled chicken
2 pint sides

Your choice of:    
Baked Beans, Potato Salad, Mac and Cheese, Cole Slaw, Corn Bread, Applesauce
8 buns
Add $2.00 per pound for Beef Brisket  

Pulled Pork by the Pound
$11.49 lb.
Pulled Chicken by the Pound
$11.49 lb.

Beef brisket by the Pound
$14.49 lb.

Superior Subs, Sides, & Rolls

Find all your favorite subs, rolls, and sides at Timmy's Pizza and BBQ. Rolls are 12 inches long, and each side has a portion size of 4 ounces.
Italian Submarines

Full subs are approximately 12" to 14"
  This irresistible sandwich is topped with ham, salami, lettuce, onions, green peppers and mozzarella cheese and pizza sauce on a submarine bun. If you want a sandwich with a tons of meat, tihs is the one for you!
Half $6.25 / Whole $9.25
Ham and Cheese
This tender, juicy sandwich will fill your appetite. It is loaded with tender ham, mozarella cheese and pizza sauce. Super this tasty sandwich with fresh toppings for an additional charge.

Half $5.25 / Whole $8.25
Chicken Club
 Smoked chicken, bacon, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes & ranch dressing.
1/2 $6.25 / Whole $9.25
Timmy's Cordon Blu
Smoked chicken ham, bacon, mozzarella cheese & ranch dressing.

1/2 $6.25 / Whole $9.25
Buffalo Chicken Sub
  Smoked chicken smothered in Buffalo sauce, mozzarella cheese, onions & ranch dressing.
1/2 $6.25 / Whole $9.25
Sausage, banana peppers, onions, cheese and pizza sauce.

1/2 $6.25 / Whole $9.25
For All Above Sandwiches  
Extra vegetables: 1/2 - 50¢ Whole - $1.00
Extra Meat or Cheese: 1/2 - $1.00 Whole $2.00
Sausage Roll
  More than one gigantic foot of Italian sausage, juicy onions, and a mound of mozzarella cheese, wrapped up in our freshest pizza dough. Served with our own BBQ sauce upon request.
Pizza Roll
Build your own treat with your choice of two of any of our delicious pizza toppings o nthe same fresh pizza dough, sauce & mozzarella cheese.


Extra Vegetables: $1.00 each
Extra Meat $2.00 each
Sides are 5oz. portions
  Baked Beans, Potato Salad, Potato Chips, Cole Slaw, Applesauce, Mac and Cheese, and Corn Bread
1 side

2 sides

Chef Salad
 Fresh crisp lettuce, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses, egg, onions, juicy bell peppers, plump tomatoes and delicious ham sliced thin and served chilled with your choice of dressing.
Taco Salad
First, we start with a bed of crunchy taco chips, then load on the lettuce, next comes the mixture of cheddar and mozzarella cheese, onions, green pepper, fresh tomatoes and seasoned beef. Taco sauce & sour cream available upon request.

Tossed Salad
  Fresh lettuce covered in onions, juicy bell peppers and plump tomatoes served with your choice of dressing.

Cake Rolls - Homemade in House
  Strawberries and Cream
Flavor of the Week

$2.49 / $16 Whole
Elephant Ears
Hand stretched dough with cinnamon sugar and butter topped with powdered sugar


2 Liter Pop
Carry Out Only
SPECIAL NOTE: Due to the smoked process, all meat may have a pink interior color

$3.00 Delivery Fee up to 3 miles, add $1.00 per mile for distances greater than 3 miles

Timmy's Pizza and BBQ
15805 Lima Rd.
Huntertown, IN 46748
For catering up to 1000 people
For catering up
to 1000 people
For catering up to 1000 people
For catering up to
1000 people
Back to content